Robin Hood rocks the RSA

by Robin Hood

Posted in: Action reports, Campaign updates, Latest, Opinion, Top stories

‘It’s a simple and beautiful idea that has found its time,’ said Bill Nighy as he introduced the Robin Hood Tax campaign film to the packed audience at the RSA (Royal Society for the encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce) this morning.

He went on to admit: ‘I’m not an economist, but I am wearing green tights under my trousers.’

A message to Robin Hood Tax supporters from Bill Nighy

Nighy was on top form as he joined fellow campaigner Richard Curtis, Professor Jeffrey Sachs, international economist and author of The End of Poverty, Major Ivor Teller, Assistant Secretary for Programme Salvation Arny, and Dr Clare Melamed, Head of Policy Co-ordination Action Aid, for a lively discussion on the Robin Hood Tax. Alan Beattie, World Trade editor at the Financial Times, chaired the event.

Missed the event? Watch it again on the RSA website >>

The session kicked off with an address by Jeffrey Sachs. Sachs is optimistic for the tax and sees it as a real opportunity to bring change on a global scale.

‘Something will happen if we are vigilant,’ he said. He referenced the historic moment five years ago at the Gleneagles G8 meeting when public support for the Make Poverty History campaign resulted in a pledge to increase aid by $50 billion.

Jeffrey Sachs discussing the Robin Hood Tax at the RSA event, LondonThat pledge is now $21 billion short and he argued that the Robin Hood Tax, in addition to supporting public services in the UK, could also be used to plug this gap in international aid. Sachs stressed the importance in honouring the life and death commitments made at Gleneagles.

‘The financial sector is undertaxed and out of control,’ he continued, talking about the banks bail out and recent bankers bonuses,’ he added, ‘We bailed them out and they put it in their pockets.’

Sachs argued that not only do the markets need to be regulated and taxed, but the campaign also needs to have a component that will hold the US to account.

As Sachs spoke the event was livecast across the web and the Robin Hood Tax became a trending topic on Twitter as questions were sent in for the panel.

‘This campaign is a glimpse of the future,’ said Richard Curtis, as he took to the podium to talk about his passion and support for the campaign. On the bankers he said: ‘There are brilliant and serious men who have applied their wit and brain power to making money. They now need to apply themselves to working out how they can say ‘yes’ to this.’

Curtis, director of films such as Four Weddings and a Funeral and Love Actually, was a big supporter of the Jubilee Debt campaign and believes in the power of the public to drive this campaign.The panel at the RSA event to discuss the Robin Hood Tax

‘500,000 women still die in childbirth, and that has to be sorted out,’ he said,  ‘I’ve been surprised and delighted by the public response. Lets think, argue and see if we can make it happen.’

A lively debate followed, with one of the top questions being, will this cost be passed onto us, the banks customers?

Claire Melamed, Head of Policy at Action Aid tackled this by pointing to the large amount of research that has been done on what happens historically in the financial markets. She said: ‘It is a much fairer way of doing it, (raising revenue), much fairer than raising VAT which has the opposite effect.’

Reaction from participants and guests

Other questions posed included how can we manage transactions that are happening across the globe, how will that money will be controlled and allocated and how will we ensure that the money is used effectively. All the questions were answered by the panel and you will be able to watch or listen to the full debate a little later this week.

The Salvation Army, one of the charity coalition partners has seen first hand through their work how 1 in 5 currently live in poverty in the UK. ‘The moral argument is clear,’ said Major Ivor Telfer, Salvation Army, ‘The poor are getting poorer and the rich need to step in and give a hand up, not a hand out.’

Missed the event? Want to watch it again ? >>

A message to Robin Hood Tax campaign supporters from Jeffrey Sachs after the RSA event


Want to support the campaign for the Robin Hood tax? Take action now >>

  • Harriet
    @Jack: If you read what is being called for you will see that 50% of the revenue raised is called for being spent domestically - that is, by the UK Government - on things like the NHS, schools, care for the elderly and disabled, and even police. Exactly what it would be spent on would be a political decision and certainly not up to those calling for the tax.

    Half of what's left would go to International Development. Increasingly, money for development is being given as budget support, not delivered through the third sector. In other words, many organisations backing the tax would actually quite like the funds to go into instruments like Sector Wide Approaches which help poor governments pay for teachers and nurses in their own public sector because their own tax bases are too small.

    The remainder would go to climate change, the instruments for which are still under negotiation. Again, much of this money will be spent by or through governments, often on solutions ultimately provided by the private sector (energy efficient power plants, renewable energy, and so on).

    I respectfully think your opinion is based on a misunderstanding on what is really being called for here.
  • Jack Pearson
    I'm not misunderstanding anything.

    Who chose the organizations to be included in this plans?

    Who chose to not let other organizations in the plans?

    Who are THEY to determine where a country's tax money should be diverted?

    3 questions that I'd like 3 answers to.

    Thanks.
  • Thanks Jack. Harriet's spot on here. The organisations listed here are those who support the idea behind this campaign, because they can see it would have a large impact on the areas they work in or people they work for. We're most certainly not trying to draw up some sort of list of organisations who might derive some direct benefit from the tax.

    No-one actively chose the organisations who're backing it - they chose themselves by seeking to get involved as supporters of the campaign. Other organisations are joining us all the time to add their voices to the call. First off there were around a dozen backers, as the weeks have gone by it's now nearly a hundred - fingers crossed it'll get support even more widely than that.
  • Sally
    @Jack - All good ideas have to start somewhere - why harp on about it's roots? What is the point that you are trying to make?
  • Jack Pearson
    When certain charitable organizations are no longer satisfied with charitable donations from individuals & businesses, and decide to coerce money via forcing taxation law changes within entire countries, it's time to find other charitable organizations to donate your hard earned money. The vast majority of charitable organizations aren't part of this taxation scheme. Maybe they deserve some attention instead of the ones shown on this site. Just my opinion.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Get regular updates

Sherwood Echo Weekly Sherwood Echo
A breath of forest air every Friday lunchtime by email. The week's events and top links from Robin.
 
RSS feed Instant updates by RSS
Subscribe to our main RSS feed for alerts whenever we add new info to this site.
 
Email alerts Daily email alerts
A nice simple email every time we update the site.
 
Supporter special email Supporter special
Signup above and get our gorgeous 'supporter special' in your inbox every few weeks.